Ithaca Prospect LLC & Anor v Lloyd’s Insurance Company SA & Ors -The Ithaca Prospect

From DMC
Jump to navigationJump to search

DMC/INS/26/03

England

Ithaca Prospect LLC & Anor v Lloyd’s Insurance Company SA & Ors (The “Ithaca Prospect”)

English Commercial Court: Peter MacDonald Eggers KC (sitting as a Deputy Judge of the High Court): [2026] EWHC 2700 (Comm): 21 October 2026

Judgment Available on BAILII @ https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Comm/2026/2700.html

Stephen Hofmeyr KC and Emma Franklin (instructed by Mays Brown Ltd) for Ithaca (Owners/Insureds)

Oliver Caplin KC and Eliza Bond (instructed by Kennedys Law LLP) for Lloyd’s and others (Underwriters)

MARINE INSURANCE: WAR RISKS: BLOCKING AND TRAPPING: SUE AND LABOUR: NOTICE OF CANCELLATION: NOTICE OF ABANDONMENT: DEEMED CONSTRUCTIVE TOTAL LOSS: SECTIONS 62, 63, AND 78 OF THE MARINE INSURANCE ACT 1906

Summary

The High Court, in finding that Owners were only entitled to succeed in part against Underwriters under the war risks insurance policy, held that:

(1)  As to USD1.2m claimed as expenses for crewing costs (USD550k), bunker costs (USD192k) and legal fees:

(a)  Owners were entitled to recover the crewing costs and bunker costs under the policy as sue and labour expenses, having incurred those expenses to avoid or minimise a CTL, and part only of the legal fees, because some legal fees related to Ukraine’s arrest of and Owners’ attempted exercise of a lien on the cargo. These latter fees concerned separate criminal and commercial law issues; they were not incurred to avoid or minimise a CTL;

(b)  Owners were not entitled to recover port fees, because these had been incurred, in view of the terms of the settlement agreement reached between Owners and Underwriters, to facilitate the sale of the vessel to a third party. This occurred after the vessel had already become a deemed CTL.  Therefore, those fees had not been incurred to avoid or minimise a CTL; and

(2)  Owners were unable to recover about USD2.3m that they had claimed as replacement insurance costs, because Underwriters had never accepted Owners’ notices of abandonment.  This meant that the costs, despite having been incurred to preserve or protect the vessel and Owners’ interests in her, remained a “liability of ownership”.  Thus, they never transferred to Underwriters as they would have done, had they accepted notice of abandonment.

As a result, Owners were only entitled to recover in part under the policy.  The quantification of the legal fees that were partly recoverable under (1)(a) above would have to be determined at a later date as a consequential issue.

Case note contributed by Jim Leighton, LLM (Maritime Law), LLB (Hons), BSc (Hons), Solicitor Advocate of England & Wales, IMI Registered Mediator, LMAA Supporting Member and Deputy Editor of DMC’s CaseNotes

Background

On 10 February 2022, Owners fixed their vessel, “Ithaca Prospect”, to perform a one time charter trip to carry a muriate of potash cargo from Ukraine to the US Gulf.  She was expected to depart drydock at Varna, Bulgaria on 20 February 2022.

Underwriters on 17 February 2022 issued notice of cancellation of the vessel’s war risk policy, which would expire at midnight on 1 March 2022, after Lloyd’s Joint War Risks Committee updated its Listed Areas (entry to which requires an additional premium to be paid due to the higher war risks faced therein) to include Ukrainian and Russian waters in the Black Sea and the Sea of Azov.

The vessel arrived at Mykolaiv, Ukraine on 21 February 2022.  She was at that time expected to complete loading the cargo by 24 February 2022 and then to depart the Listed Areas before the notice of cancellation would have expired.

However, on 24 February Russia invaded Ukraine.  Shortly thereafter, before the vessel could complete loading, Ukraine imposed martial law and closed most seaports.  A further announcement on 25 February 2022 confirmed, after the connecting channel had been mined, that entry/exit to Mykolaiv was closed.

Owners and Underwriters were unable to agree terms and premiums for the call to this Listed Area after the notice of cancellation expired.  Owners sought and obtained replacement insurance cover. However, the premiums were very expensive, being USD2.3m to cover from 2 March to 12 April 2022, compared to the USD16m insured value of the vessel.  So, Owners ceased to insure her.

The vessel had been able to complete the loading of the cargo and had issued mate’s receipts to shippers.  However, despite Owners maintaining her ready to depart, in case such an opportunity should arise, by incurring expenses of USD1.2m for crewing, bunkers and various legal fees, she was, in the event, detained for more than 12 months; as a result the vessel became a deemed constructive total loss (CTL) under the war risks policy.

During the course of the vessel’s detention, some of the legal fees incurred by Owners related to Ukraine arresting the cargo, in relation to an alleged criminal law case against its own customs officials, and Owners seeking to exercise a lien on the cargo, in relation to commercial law issues, concerning the termination of the one time charter trip and sums due thereunder and related to the cargo.

Owners issued three notices of abandonment after the vessel had been detained for more than 12 months.  Underwriters declined to accept those notices.  However, Underwriters accepted the vessel had become a deemed CTL under the policy.  The parties then concluded a settlement agreement.  That agreement came into binding effect when the vessel was sold, on an “as is, where is” basis, to a third party, whereby Owners would be paid her insured value by Underwriters after her ownership had been transferred to purchasers. To facilitate that sale, to enable the vessel to depart, Owners incurred the expense of port fees too.

Following the sale, with the settlement agreement having not settled all heads of claim in dispute between the parties, Owners sought to claim from Underwriters expenses related to crewing, bunkers consumed, legal fees and port fees, as sue and labour expenses, as well as the replacement insurance costs, under the policy. Underwriters declined to pay any of the expenses or the costs, as a result of which Owners commenced legal proceedings in the English High Court.

Judgment

The Judge outlined the key facts and terms of the war risks policy (fn.1) and the settlement agreement (fn.2), and summarised the relevant legal principles.

The Judge noted that the principal issues that arose for determination were whether Owners were entitled to recover under the policy:

(1) Expenses incurred by Owners related to crewing and bunker consumption of the vessel, various legal fees and port fees, as sue and labour expenses; and

(2) Costs incurred by Owners to obtain replacement insurance, after cancellation of the policy, as a liability of the vessel’s ownership transferred on abandonment.

As to (1) above, the judge noted that section 78(4) of the Marine Insurance Act 1906 (MIA) imposes a duty to sue and labour, i.e. to mitigate loss, requiring insureds to “take such measures as may be reasonable for the purpose of averting or minimising a loss”.  Beyond expenses needing to be incurred to mitigate, to avoid or minimise, imminent or operative insured perils, such as a CTL, expenses must be proper and reasonably incurred, the circumstances must involve unusual or extraordinary steps and expenses, the purpose of such steps and expenses being to preserve the insured property, and, if loss or damage had occurred, that loss or damage must have been one insured under the policy.

On the heads of claim for the expenses incurred, the Judge determined that:

The crew-related vessel and bunkers expenses incurred by Owners were recoverable under the policy as sue and labour expenses, incurred in seeking to avoid or to minimise a CTL, because those expenses enabled the vessel to be protected or preserved and kept ready to depart if the opportunity arose, which, under the circumstances faced, were of an extraordinary and unusual nature.

The legal fees incurred by Owners specifically to investigate and pursue the possibility of the vessel being able to depart were recoverable as sue and labour expenses because they were incurred to seek to avoid or to minimise a CTL, and had also arisen under the extraordinary and unusual circumstances faced.

The legal fees (which were yet to be quantified) incurred by Owners relating to Ukraine’s arrest of the cargo, on a separate criminal law issue, and relating to Owners’ attempt to exercise a lien on the cargo, on separate commercial law issues for claims against charterers and cargo interests, were not recoverable because they had not been incurred to seek to avoid or to minimise a CTL.

The port fees were not recoverable as sue and labour expenses.  The fees were, pursuant to the settlement agreement, incurred by Owners to facilitate the sale of the vessel to a third party, in return for Underwriters paying her insured value to Owners.  Owners had also incurred the fees only after the vessel had already become a CTL, so they were not incurred to avoid or to minimise a CTL.

As to (2) above, the Judge noted that, pursuant to sections 62 and 63 of MIA (fn.3), where there has been acceptance by insurers of a notice of abandonment of the insured vessel by insureds, the abandonment of the vessel operates retrospectively from the date of the casualty, and insurers are also then entitled to elect to take over all the benefits and burdens of ownership of the vessel.  However, the mere payment of a CTL is not itself an acceptance of abandonment, or an election to take over all the benefits and burdens of owning the vessel.

The Judge determined that the replacement insurance costs were not recoverable from Underwriters, despite being incurred to preserve or protect the vessel and Owners’ interests in her.  The costs remained a “liability of ownership” of the vessel, and her ownership had never been transferred to Underwriters, because they did not accept Owners’ notices of abandonment.  So, a liability to reimburse the costs to Owners did not arise under section 63 of MIA.

Conclusion

In all the circumstances, the Judge held that the sue and labour heads of claim for expenses incurred by Owners related to crewing and bunkers consumption of the vessel were fully recoverable, only part of the legal fees (with quantum to be determined as a consequential issue) were recoverable, and the heads of claim for port fees expenses and replacement insurance costs were dismissed.

Comment

This judgment seems to be the first reported decision related to a vessel blocking and trapping dispute following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. The dispute in this case partly centered on which heads of claim were recoverable under the policy as sue and labour expenses incurred in seeking to avoid or minimise a CTL.

This case is a useful reminder that not all expenses a shipowner incurs may be recoverable as sue and labour expenses: recoverability may depend on when the expenses are incurred (before or after a CTL arises) and the purpose for which the expenses are incurred (whether or not to avoid or minimise a CTL).

One oddity arising related to the replacement insurance costs issue was that if Owners had instead agreed terms and premium with Underwriters, after Underwriters’ notice of cancellation had taken effect, then those costs, incurred by Owners before abandonment, would have been recoverable under the war risks policy, had Underwriters instead accepted the vessel’s abandonment.

The above would be the case because residual proprietary ownership interests in a vessel, under section 63 of MIA, can be transferred to the abandonee-insurer.  The latter must then reimburse the abandoner-insured (ex-owner) for expenses incurred to preserve or protect the vessel or the then owner’s interests in her.  Where there are valuable rights attached to the vessel’s ownership, such as freight in the course of being earned, then accepting the vessel’s abandonment may make economic sense.  That does not seem to be the case here, which likely explains why Underwriters had pursued the settlement strategy adopted.

Footnote 1:

The Institute Time Clauses – Hulls 1/10/83, as incorporated into the war risks policy, materially state:-

“13 DUTY OF ASSURED (SUE AND LABOUR)

13.1     In case of any loss or misfortune it is the duty of the Assured and their servants and agents to take such measures as may be reasonable for the purpose of averting or minimising a loss which would be recoverable under this insurance.

13.2     Subject to the provisions below … the Underwriters will contribute to charges properly and reasonably incurred by the Assured their servants or agents for such measures. ...

13.6     The sum recoverable under this Clause 13 shall be in addition to the loss otherwise recoverable under this insurance but shall in no circumstances exceed the amount insured under this insurance in respect of the Vessel.”

Footnote 2:

The settlement agreement between Owners and Underwriters materially states:-

“Background

...

(C)       It is the Assured's position that the Vessel became a constructive total loss on or before 24 February 2023 and that they are entitled to be indemnified for the insured value in the amount of USD$16,000,000 (the “Claim”). It is accepted and Agreed by the Insurers that the Assured may have other valid claims under the Policy which do not form part of the Claim but will be considered by the Insurers in due course if and when presented ...

Agreed Terms

…

2 Entry to Force

2.1       This Agreement shall only become effective upon the signing of a contract for the Sale of the Vessel ...

3 Vessel Sale

3.1       It is the intention of the Parties for the Vessel to be sold to a third party (the “Sale”) on an as-is-where is basis with no representations or warranties provided as to the condition of the Vessel or the cargo on board. …

4 Payment

4.1       On the day the Agreement comes into force … and provided that occurs during business hours, Insurers will process immediately via their electronic claims system collection of the Settlement Sum. The funds will be collected via ... Brokers [who] will then remit the Settlement Sum to the [Assured]. …”

Footnote 3:

MIA materially states:-

“62 Notice of abandonment.

(1) Subject to the provisions of this section, where the assured elects to abandon the subject-matter insured to the insurer, he must give notice of abandonment. ...

(2) Notice of abandonment may be given in writing, or by word of mouth, or partly in writing and partly by word of mouth, and may be given in any terms which indicate the intention of the assured to abandon his insured interest in the subject-matter insured unconditionally to the insurer.

(3) Notice of abandonment must be given with reasonable diligence after the receipt of reliable information of the loss, ...

(4) Where notice of abandonment is properly given, the rights of the assured are not prejudiced by the fact that the insurer refuses to accept the abandonment.

(5) The acceptance of an abandonment may be either express or implied from the conduct of the insurer. The mere silence of the insurer after notice is not an acceptance.

(6) Where notice of abandonment is accepted the abandonment is irrevocable. The acceptance of the notice conclusively admits liability for the loss and the sufficiency of the notice. …”

“63 Effect of abandonment.

(1) Where there is a valid abandonment the insurer is entitled to take over the interest of the assured in whatever may remain of the subject-matter insured, and all proprietary rights incidental thereto.

(2) Upon the abandonment of a ship, the insurer thereof is entitled to any freight in course of being earned, and which is earned by her subsequent to the casualty causing the loss, less the expenses of earning it incurred after the casualty; ...”